APS vs. Square Payroll: Which is Best? - Wheelhouse

APS vs. Square Payroll: Which is Best?

APS vs. Square Payroll Best Overall: APS

In our comparison of APS vs. Square Payroll, APS is the best option with a higher overall Wheelhouse Score. Wheelhouse Score uses a combination of feature and pricing comparison data, average user ratings, and editorial reviews to score software vendors on a scale of 1-10.

Quick Info

APS Quick Info
WH Score:
9.0
Pricing Score:
8.6
Feature Score:
9.2
Usability Score:
8.5
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:
Square Payroll Quick Info
WH Score:
5.7
Pricing Score:
5.7
Feature Score:
5.9
Usability Score:
5.4
Company Size:All Sizes
Platforms:

Pricing

APS Pricing
Price Range
Contact Us

* Vendor does not share prices.

Square Payroll Pricing
Pay Contractors Only
$5
per employee / per month
Pay Employees & Contractors
$5
per employee / per month

Features

APS Features
  • Paystubs
  • Pay Runs
  • Garnishments
  • Timesheets
  • Time Off Management
  • Break Management
  • Shift Management
  • Tax Calculation & Filing
  • Tax Policy Management
  • W-2
  • 1094
  • 1095
  • Job Posting
  • Applicant Tracking System (ATS)
  • Employee Records
Square Payroll Features
  • Paystubs
  • Pay Runs
  • Garnishments
  • Timesheets
  • Time Off Management
  • Break Management
  • Shift Management
  • Tax Calculation & Filing
  • Tax Policy Management
  • W-2
  • 1094
  • 1095
  • Job Posting
  • Applicant Tracking System (ATS)
  • Employee Records

Pros & Cons

APS Pros & Cons
Pros
  • This software is very easy to use, customer service is very fast to respond, we are allowed to automate importing payroll transaction into GL.
Cons
  • There are occasional issues with the portal not functioning properly
  • Additionally, I would like to see additional features like helpful pop-ups to make navigating the website easier.
Square Payroll Pros & Cons
Pros
    Cons

      Reviews

      APS Reviews
      Top Favorable Review
      R
      Robert
      Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

      This software is very easy to use, customer service is very fast to respond, we are allowed to automate importing payroll transaction into GL.

      Setting up the start dates from the HR module, and additional automation is a bit hard.

      Top Critical Review
      J
      Jose
      Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021

      APS is a good solution for anyone looking to streamline their payroll process. The initial integration can be challenging, but once you get the hang of it, the software is very user-friendly and efficient.

      The customer service is excellent, and I appreciate the ease of access to the portal.

      There are occasional issues with the portal not functioning properly. Additionally, I would like to see additional features like helpful pop-ups to make navigating the website easier.

      Square Payroll Reviews
      Top Favorable Review

      N/A

      Top Critical Review

      N/A

      Alternatives

      APS Alternatives
      Square Payroll Alternatives
      Add to Compare

      Add suggested to comparison

      APS vs. Square Payroll: Detailed Comparison

      APS vs. Square Payroll Top Ratings & Reviews: APS

      In our rating and review comparison of APS vs. Square Payroll, APS has 87 user reviews and Square Payroll has 0. The average star rating for APS is 4.83 while Square Payroll has an average rating of 0.0. APS has more positive reviews than Square Payroll. Comparing APS vs. Square Payroll reviews, APS has stronger overall reviews.

      APS vs. Square Payroll Best Features & Functionality: APS

      APS vs. Square Payroll both offer a strong set of features and functionality including Payroll Management, Attendance Management, Tax Management, Supported Tax Forms, Talent Management , Employee Management, Reporting & Analytics, Workforce Optimization, Cash Flow Management, Payment Options, Clock-In/Clock-Out Options, Portal Types, Collaboration Tools, Appointments/Scheduling, Reminders/Alerts, Identity and Access Management (IAM), Cybersecurity Features, File Management, Compliance Accreditations, Accounting Features, Data Management, After-Sales Service, Project Management Features, Signature Management. In our feature comparison of APS vs. Square Payroll, APS offers more of the most popular features and tools than Square Payroll.

      APS vs. Square Payroll Best Pricing: Square Payroll

      In our pricing comparison of APS vs. Square Payroll, Square Payroll's pricing starts at $5/month and is more affordable compared to Square Payroll's starting cost of $5/month.

      APS vs. Square Payroll Best Usability: APS

      Our comparison of APS vs. Square Payroll shows that APS scores higher in usability for ease of use, meets requirements, learning curve, setup & support, quality of support, ease of admin. Square Payroll scores higher in , but APS has the best scores overall for system usability.

      The right software for your business

      Get your personalized recommendations now.